Nagornokarabakh has been a frozen conflict for more than a decade, but tensions have remained high since a breakdown in talks that followed the april 2016 violence, with repeated ceasefire. The article analyzes the cases of the european court of human rights related to human rights violations during the armeniaazerbaijan nagornokarabakh conflict. I the sources of the conflict are the subject of much an ethnic conifict debate. Several cases of skirmishes, escalating in 2016 during the fourday war, demonstrate the security threat the conflict represents. Legally, it is a clash between the law of territorial integrity for azerbaijan and the right to selfdetermination for nagornokarabakh. However, in some crucial respects, the conflict over nagornokarabakh is unique when compared to the conflicts in georgia, tajikistan, moldova, and in russias ethnic republic of chechnya. Yes, it is much easier to solve karabakh conflict from the legal point of view if we go to the roots of the conflict. The armenian enp and conflict resolution in nagorno karabakh2 the enp as a key step towards a longterm sustainable resolution of the nagornokarabakh conflict. Peacebuilding and conflict resolution in nagornokarabakh. Karabakh conflict emerged in the beginning of the twentieth. In soviet times this enclave, called nagorno karabakh autonomous region hereinafter referred as. In this respect, the current developments in the cases of kosovo, abkhazia and south ossetia are also taken into account. The nagornokarabakh conflict between armenia and azerbaijan remains one of the worlds most intractable and longstanding territorial and ethnic disputes.
Once more, while elaborating on the nagornokarabakh conflict, perhaps we should not start by drawing all the obvious advantages of peace against war, andor present the status quo against any type of grassrootslevel cooperation. It also contains elaboration on the principle of territorial integrity versus selfdetermination. Nagornokarabakh after two decades of conflict regional. The landlocked mountainous region of nagornokarabakh is the subject of an unresolved dispute between azerbaijan, in which it lies, and its ethnic armenian majority, backed by neighbouring armenia. Baku, osce minsk group mull settlement of nagornokarabakh conflict 21 april 10. Azerbaijanitaly relations 977 words exact match in snippet view article find links to article osce minsk groups acting for the peaceful settlement of the nagornokarabakh conflict. The nagornokarabakh conflict a legal analysis heiko. It has since been repopulated by armenian settlers and is the capital of the republic of artsakhs shahumyan region, which has radically. After giving a brief description of the galtung conflict triangle and short asymmetry and symmetry analysis,i will examine the nagorno karabakh conflict. As european norms receive a deeper and broader recognition, so do new alternatives to the classical powerbased conflict resolution approaches. The ethnoterritorial conflict over nagornokarabakh has a multidimensional nature that involves political, socioeconomic, and securityrelated issues ranging from territorial disputes to ethnic hostility. Karabakh, an autonomous region contested by both azerbaijan and armenia, began in february 1988 following a series of strikes and demonstrations held by armenians living. Competing legal, historic and economic claims in political, academic and media discourses the armeniaazerbaijan conflict over the. It discusses not only the history of the nagornokarabakh conflict and what went wrong with the minsk groups attempts to find a fair and objective solution to the conflict, but also the obstacles and opportunities for a settlement.
To this end, iclaw conducts research and performs legal analysis. The nagornokarabakh conflict the nagornokarabakh conflict between armenia and azerbaijan remains one of the worlds most intractable and longstanding territorial and ethnic disputes. The analysis concentrates on two aspects of the nagornokarabakh conflict. First chapter deals with the history and the status of nagornokarabakh region of azerbaijan. Thus, any analysis of the nagornokarabakh conflict should be clarified in all aspects or in a resolution process.
The nagornokarabakh dispute and the regional context marilisa lorusso dubbed the fourday war, the early april clashes between azerbaijan and the breakaway region of nagornokarabakh south caucasus shed renewed light on the long lasting dispute, frozen since the. Summary of the volume turkey and the karabakh conflict in 1990s. As the conflict has remained dormant for more than 20 years, the political systems of the countries engaged in the. In was forced to who had conditionally accepted the plan, resign. Roundtable report a united states institute of peace. Conclusion the karabakh region as a whole, and its mountainous part nk, has been a historic part of azerbaijan and populated by a majority azerbaijani population for the past several centuries. The nagornokarabakh conflict masarykova univerzita. The stalemate over karabakh will be analyzed on the domestic, regional and. In our analysis of the conflict, we will concentrate on the legal aspect of the. The history of the nagorno karabakh conflict in legal documents the analysis of the legal aspects of the nagorno karabakh conflict requires delving into the history and finding the roots of the problem. The book deals with the problem of nagornokarabakh in contemporary international law. Brenda shaffer nagornokarabakh after crimea, may 3, 2014 is right that a reenergized u. Armenia, meanwhile, says that nagornokarabakh has no future as a part of azerbaijan and believes that the conflict must be resolved with the recognition of.
The minsk groups cochairs could put azerbaijan and armenia on the road to resolution. The plan was accepted by azerbaijan, with reservations by armenia, and rejected out of hand by accepted february 1998, the president of armenia, nagornokarabakh. Pdf nagornokarabakh conflict in international legal. A new legal approach towards the nagornokarabakh conflict. The aim of this analysis is to gain expertise and insights that could prove relevant to resolving the conflict in nagornokarabakh. On the basis of a legal analysis of the courts judgments, the author disposes that the court is not only authorized to examine human rights violations during armed conflicts, and to. Sudden increase of violence on the international level occurred in the period of fall of soviet union and followed by the horrible events of wars in yugoslavia and genocide in rwanda. The article explores the current stalemate in the nagorny karabakh conflict, and perspectives for conflict transformation. This potential is evaluated in the closing chapters of the volume where novel ideas on how to apply the lessons of these cases to. Pdf an analysis of the nagornokarabakh conflict according to.
Nagornokarabakh dispute is regarded as one of the frozen conflicts, which has. Nkr in accordance with soviet law and international law, and involvement of. The nagornokarabakh conflict a legal analysis heiko kruger. The conflict has its origins in the early 20th century.
The armenianspeaking population became majority only in the 20th century, after an out migration of the. A lack of sophisticated analysis of the problem of ethnic violence is not the problem. The aim of this treatise is therefore to focus more strongly on the legal positions, and in particular to underline the importance of principles of international law in connection with the nagornokarabakh conflict. The nagornokarabakh conflict 5 ruling families destroyed the local armenian elite. Politics and security hold each other hostage in nagornokarabakh but frustration with the peace process will grow unless both foreign ministers address the critical political aspects of a future settlement. This dissertation focuses on the conflict of nagornokarabakh.
But she errs in ignoring the role of the nagornokarabakh republic in. This redrawing of borders and territorial lines, which were designed to create territorial disputes among the republics in order to keep them weak, set in motion the conflict over nagornokarabakh. Before speaking about the legal aspects of the nagornokarabakh conflict, we should tackle some issues concerning the legal status of this territory. Armenian captured not only the territory of nagorno karabakh, but key surrounding areas such as the lachin. Pdf the consequences of the nagornokarabakh war for. The caucasus region, situated on a natural isthmus between the black sea and the caspian sea, has long been a. This article endeavours to bring into the spotlight currently an analysis and discussion of the conflict in nagornokarabakh, which is considered to be a frozen conflict following dissolution of the soviet union. In 1718th centuries armenians were fighting against the persian dominancy1. This is a very good legal analysis of the conflict between armenia and azerbaijan.
It was captured by armenian forces during the battle of kalbajar, near the end of the nagornokarabakh war. A legal analysis of chinas historic rights claim in the south. Nagornokarabakh news, news on nagornokarabakh conflict. This led to the region slipping out of armenian control, and an azeri ruler managed to impose his rule and create a semiindependent dynastic rule, the khanate of karabakh, based in shusha. Nagornokarabakh conflict between armenia and azerbaijan. The problem of nagornokarabakh and international law. Pdf the nagorno karabakh conflict the beginning of the soviet. Politics and security hold each other hostage in nagorno. Nagornokarabakh lies within azerbaijan territory but has a majority armenian population. Nagornokarabakh was placed under the jurisdiction of the azerbaijani soviet republic by thensoviet nationalities commissioner josef stalin.
Throughout the dissertation several key aspects and theories of international relations are analysed, such as. Its fragile nopeace, nowar situation poses a serious threat to stability in the south caucasus region and beyond. The end of xx century was marked by horrible atrocities. An analysis of the nagorno karabakh conflict politics essay. It was first presented during the seminar entitled nagornokarabakh conflict which was held at the university of southern denmark on 24 february 2011. Why the osce keeps failing to make peace in nagornokarabakh. The second chapter deals with the involvement of armenia to the conflict. A war between the two countries over the region from 19881994 claimed 30,000 lives and displaced a million people, mostly azerbaijanis in territories adjacent to nagornokarabakh that remain under the control of ethnic armenian forces. The nagorny karabakh conflict, involving armenia and azerbaijan, poses a.
The caucasus region, situated on a natural isthmus between the black sea and the caspian sea, has long been a border zone and a melting pot for a diverse range of cultures and peoples. The european court of human rights and the armed conflict. Download the pdf the nagornokarabakh conflict has been one of the most important issues on the agenda of armenia, nagornokarabakh and azerbaijan from early 1988 until now. This briefing, the first in a series of crisis group publications on covid19 and its effects on the conflict landscape, draws primarily from the input of our analysts across the globe, and identifies seven trends to watch during the pandemic. The main parties to the nagorno karabakh conflict are armenia and azerbaijan, independent. Pdf executive publisher csilla morauszki icrp geopolitika kft. This is the short presentation of nagornokarabakh conflict between armenia and azerbaijan.
Affected civilians of both sides of conflict wait for peace and justice to come fidh situation note as old as the soviet union collapse, one of the most disastrous conflicts in the region of the last 30 years, concerning the status of nagornokarabakh1, continues to kill. But we have to accept that official declarations are somewhat limited in terms of information, details of any resolution process are always hidden. Involvement of the republic of armenia in the conflict of nagornokarabakh. Russian partnership to end the conflict in nagornokarabakh would be worthwhile. On the one hand the legitimacy or illegitimacy of the secession of nagornokarabakh is scrutinised in accordance with soviet law and international law.
Legal reevaluation of the nagornokarabakh conflict. Armenia, the european court of human rights decided that the republic of armenia, from the early days of the nagornokarabakh conflict, has had a significant and decisive influence over the nkr, that the two entities are highly integrated in virtually all important matters and that this situation persists to this day. Azerbaijans position on karabakh conflict solution is based on the principle of territorial integrity of the state and on the international law. The current research aims at proposing a new approach concerning the nagornokarabakh conflict between the republic of armenia, the nagornokarabakh artsakh republic on one hand and the azerbaijani republic on the other. The nagorny karabakh conflict, involving armenia and azerbaijan, poses a major threat to.
Starting that time the armenians of karabakh apply to the. Pdf on feb 21, 2020, ali askerov and others published the. In short, the nagornokarabakh war fits the pattern of conflicts in and around the former soviet union all too well. The enduring deadlock in peace negotiations between armenia and azerbaijan over nagornokarabakh has created a special, frozen phase in the conflict cycle. Oil, democracy and the globalization of the nagorno karabakh. Azerbaijani understanding of the minsk process is that it could very well lead to the legal.
1497 1286 234 284 176 19 1562 477 863 195 1209 548 1276 1455 1019 484 1315 1391 1282 523 739 506 771 825 505 1160 349 1278 1544 330 1185 251 990 1495 1389 996 152 447 912